October 19, 2026

Paid Lead Sites for Canadian Contractors Compared (2026): HomeStars, Angi, Bark, Thumbtack and Google

Every lead site promises the same thing: homeowners looking for your trade, sent straight to you. The questions that matter are which ones actually work in Canada, what each lead costs, and what happens when the lead goes nowhere.

Here’s how the main ones compare for Canadian contractors in 2026, including HomeStars, the Canadian site most trades have been called about. (Angi’s Canadian lead site is HomeStars, so it’s covered there.) We’ve linked the sources, and where something is only what other pros say, we’ve said so.

The quick version

Site Works for Canadian trades? How you pay Pay if you don’t win?
HomeStars Yes, across Canada A fee each time a homeowner shortlists you Yes, but some bad leads can be credited
Google Local Services Ads Yes, for listed trades Per valid call, message or booking Yes, but bad leads can be credited
Bark Yes Credits to contact a customer Yes, but fake or invalid leads can be credited
Thumbtack Not that we found (US only) n/a in Canada n/a in Canada

HomeStars

HomeStars is the big Canadian one, and it’s owned by Angi. Since January 2025 there’s no membership fee for new pros. You pay a fee when a homeowner shortlists you and shares their contact details. The fee depends on the job and you see it before you respond. Pros report paying roughly $30 to $70 a lead.

We went through it in detail, including the refund rules and what pros say, in Is HomeStars worth it for contractors?

Google Local Services Ads

These are the ads at the very top of Google. They’re available in Canada for a set list of trades, including plumbers, HVAC, electricians, roofers, pest control, locksmiths and movers. Painters, renovators and general contractors aren’t on the list. You pay per valid lead, set a weekly budget, and can dispute bad leads or get automatic credits.

The badge is now called Google Verified, and the old money-back guarantee is gone. Your Google reviews affect where you rank. Full details in our guide to Google Local Services Ads in Canada.

Bark

Bark has a Canadian site where pros buy credit packs and spend them to contact customers. Bark says the cost of contacting a customer depends on the service, the value of the job and supply and demand in the area. It doesn’t publish a credit price in Canadian dollars.

A few things to know:

  • Credits expire three months after you buy them.
  • You pay whether or not you win. Bark says it’s a pay-per-introduction marketplace and can’t guarantee the customer will respond.
  • There’s a guarantee on your first pack. Bark says it returns your credits if you don’t win any business with the first one. It also has a credit-back policy for leads with fake or invalid contact details.
  • Check demand in your trade and city. Bark has Canadian pages for plumbers, electricians and roofers, but it doesn’t publish how many Canadian leads each category gets, and its featured categories lean toward cleaning, gardening and fencing.

On Trustpilot, Bark has a 3.8 TrustScore from over 112,000 reviews, mostly from customers. The pros’ complaints we read were about customers who never answered. One Canadian pro wrote that Bark refunded their credits for an inactive lead.

Angi

If you’ve read about Angi (formerly Angie’s List), that’s mostly the US. Angi’s annual report lists HomeStars as its Canadian home services marketplace. HomeStars’ own site says the same thing: “Canada: HomeStars”. So for a Canadian contractor, Angi means HomeStars.

Angi does run a separate gig-style app, Angi Services (formerly Handy), that says it operates in major US and Canadian cities. That’s for picking up small jobs from a list, not a lead feed for a trade business.

Thumbtack

Thumbtack’s own list of states covers the 50 US states and DC, and no Canadian provinces. A Thumbtack staff member said in 2022 that it didn’t offer services in Canada, and we found nothing newer. If you see Thumbtack reviews online, they’re about the US.

The same three complaints everywhere

We read a small sample of what pros post on Trustpilot about HomeStars, Angi, Bark and Thumbtack. People with a bad experience post more, so treat it as opinion. But the same complaints kept coming up:

  • Leads that never answer.
  • One lead sold to several pros.
  • Refunds that come as credits, or not at all.

In our view, the pros who do well on these sites are the ones who answer fast and already have good reviews.

Which one to try first

If your trade is on Google’s Local Services Ads list, start there with a small weekly budget. If it isn’t, HomeStars is the main Canadian option. Either way, track what each booked job actually costs you, not just what each lead costs.

Who owns the reviews

This is the part people forget. As far as we could find, reviews you earn on a lead site stay on that site and don’t show up on your Google listing. The reviews that help you on Google Maps and in Local Services Ads are your Google reviews.

Renting leads vs owning them

Lead sites aren’t bad. Plenty of contractors use one while they build up their own presence. But every one of them is a rental: the leads stop when you stop paying, and the platform sets the rules.

Your Google Business Profile is the one you own. When homeowners near you search for your trade, the businesses on the map with plenty of real reviews usually get the call, and you don’t pay per lead or share it with anyone.

That’s what we help trades build: a review request after every finished job, so your Google reviews keep climbing. See how the review system works.

Common questions

Does Bark work in Canada?

Yes. Bark has a Canadian site where pros can join and buy credits, with category pages for trades like plumbers, electricians and roofers. It doesn't publish a credit price in Canadian dollars or how many leads a trade gets in your city.

Is Angi available in Canada?

Angi's lead marketplace in Canada is HomeStars, which Angi owns. Angi does run a separate gig-style app, Angi Services, in some Canadian cities, but that isn't a lead feed for contractors.

Does Thumbtack work in Canada?

Not as far as its own pages show. Thumbtack lists only US states, and a Thumbtack staff member said in 2022 that it didn't offer services in Canada. We found nothing newer saying that's changed.

Is Bark a scam?

Bark is a real marketplace with a 3.8 TrustScore from over 112,000 Trustpilot reviews, mostly from customers. In the pro reviews we read, the common complaint was customers who never answer. Bark says it can't guarantee a response, and it offers credits back for leads with fake or invalid contact details.

Which lead site is best for contractors?

It depends on your trade, your city and how fast you answer. None of these sites publishes close rates, and none guarantees jobs. Run a small budget on one, track what each booked job costs you, and compare.

← All posts

Ready to start?

Want more Google reviews without the chasing?

We text every customer for you after the job, so the reviews land on your profile on their own.

10 days free · No contracts · Cancel anytime